Where would Auburn have been without Malzahn in 2009?
See 2008.
That is mostly true...he was the difference between what we saw last year and the huge numbers of this year.
However, I think the 2009 offense was far from being our best ever, regardless of stats. On one hand, you can't ignore the stats, the offense did produce numbers. But to me, a huge part of offense is consistency and reliability. This offense didn't really have either very often this year.
Big plays? Check. Balanced attack? Check. Kept the defense off balance a lot? Check. Reliable? Not so much. Consistent? Not so much.
In 1993, 1994, 2004, and even 2005, you just knew that if you had to grind out some plays, we could. Even if things had been stagnant for a large portion of the game, you had a feeling you could put together that one good drive (Nix to Sanders, Campbell to Taylor, Cox to Aromashodu, etc). This offense lacked that feeling of reliability and consistency.
I think another year in the system will help that, and I know that Malzahn is intent on addressing it. He's mentioned numerous times how frustrating it is that we can rattle off 10 and 25 yard plays all the way down the field, but then get stopped on 3rd and 2. So I think it will get fixed in the spring and fall practices.
If it does, and we do get some more consistency on these short yardage plays....we very well may end up with the best offense Auburn has ever seen.