I love numbers and stats, but I can't stand it when a number is thrown out there and no support is given with it.
So, 13-1 in games to someone he just lost to. Let's see if it's just genius coaching or if there are some explanations there.
In his LSU days, he had 9 losses where he played the same team the next year. Of those 9 times, he won the next meeting 8 times. The one he loss was the one to Spurrier that Scarbinski mentions (lost in 2000 and 2001).
But, if you look at his 8 wins, 5 of them were home wins...meaning he lost on the road the year before, then beat that same team in Baton Rouge the next year. Big deal.
Of the 3 wins that weren't home wins, two of them were against Ron Zook at Florida (the first against an 8-4 team, the second coming against a 7-5 team). The other road victory was against Alabama in 2003 when LSU was 13-1 and Alabama was 4-9 (the year before it was a 10-3 Alabama that beat an 8-5 LSU).
At Alabama, it's pretty simple too.
First of all, he had a 6-6 team his first year and a 12-0 team his second year. In the first year, he had losses to a 9-3 Auburn team, an 8-5 Mississippi State team, and a 12-2 LSU team. Of those 6 losses in 2007, he played 4 of those teams the next season, beating them all, which would seem to prove Scarbinski's point.
However, in 2008, he beat a 5-7 Auburn team, a 7-5 LSU team, and a 4-8 MSU team...with a 12-0 Alabama team. Only the win over Georgia was a true rebound win, beating a quality team.
So there you have the break down. Of the 13 turn around games, 5 of them were road losses followed by home wins...no big deal. Two of them were against significantly weaker Florida teams (standard Zook losses). Four of them were to teams significantly worse than the team that had beaten him the year before (Alabama in 03, Auburn, LSU, and MSU in 07). That leaves two games. One he lost, in 2001 to Spurrier, and one was last years win over Georgia.
Beating teams at home the year after losing on the road is something most coaches manage. Losing to teams with better records than you and beating teams with a worse record than you is pretty normal too. So sure Skarbinski, he only lost one of those games....but of all the wins, only 1 meant a damn thing.