My disdain for Taylor isn't a personal thing. I've met him; he's a nice guy. I just think he gets a lot of undeserved hype for coaching and recruiting. Tommy Thigpen is way more of a recruiter.
It's interesting to me you can have "disdain" for someone that's admittedly a nice guy and isn't bad at what he does.
He may not be as good of a recruiter as he's sometimes made out to be, but he certainly holds his own and isn't strictly hype by any means.
As far as being a coach...just look at the units and players he's coached everywhere he's been. He coached four receivers at Tulane that spent time in the NFL. At Tennessee he coached Riggs Jr. and Cedric Houston to be the only tandem of 1000 backs ever at UT. He coached Jayson Swain, Bret Smith and Robert Meachem at UT, then, after losing all three, he coached Lucas Taylor, Austin Rogers, and Josh Briscoe to 2,130 yards receiving the next year. (thanks wiki).
Add a pretty successful group this year, including a former nobody Darvin Adams.
Anyway, he may get some extra hype because of his personality, but I don't really get what there is to "disdain", especially considering he is one of our coaches and has hardly been a weak link in the staff or anything like that.