Cecil Hurt disagrees.
I believe on the Finebaum show, he said that if you weren't aware of Bama's football team, you would think AJ McCarron was the best QB on the practice field. And he didn't insinuate that was a good thing.
If so, it would be contrary to what everybody saw at A-Day, contrary to him coming in 2nd at the Manning Passing Academy (beating out QBs such as Sam Bradford, Colt McCoy, etc), contrary to nearly any media report coming out of camp, contrary to alot of reporters, etc. I'm not saying the guy is all-world or anything, but there has been ALOT coming out that he's pretty damn good in his own right. I know that beating out some good QBs at the MPA doesn't mean he's going to be a Heisman candidate or anything, but it doesn't give me any reason to think he's the most horrible QB either. Our own OC has said that having McElroy at QB is allowing him to open more of the playbook this coming season and do some things they couldn't do with JPW. And thats in media articles too. Again, not saying the kid is going to be a world beater. I'm curious as to exactly what is going to happen myself, but I have a good feeling about it.
In a July 19th article, Hurt said the following:
Based on personal observation, I think he will do well. His arm is good. I think that the decision-making that had to be coached into Wilson over the past two years comes more naturally for McElroy.
Now, unless something has DRASTICALLY changed in the past month......maybe he has Alzheimers. Maybe you misunderstood the context of what was being said, or what was being said altogether. Maybe Cecil Hurt doesn't know what he's talking about. I don't know. But even he said, just a few weeks ago, that McElroy was decent at the very least. Now, behind McElroy, we're totally fucked. I sung Star Jackson's praises when we got his LOI, but it seems I was wrong and he is a bust. McCarron may be the #2 QB this season. And THAT, is scary. Not because I think McCarron sucks, but he's really not ready to play in the SEC right now.