It's not about being real life picky. I don't think anyone here would turn those two girls down. In fact, those two girls would probably be the hottest females in most of the places we all like to hang out.
However, we're talking about TV hot. Internet hot. You're crazy if you think Andrews and new girl are truly up there in terms of Internet hot.
EA is world class hot! I don't give a shit what anybody says. It's not all about her looks either.
The other girl, as stated, really cute, better than I've done I hate to admit, or can remember doing, but she wouldn't stand out on campus at Auburn, Ole Miss, etc with the dozens of other "hot college chics".