Preseason in College Football?

[Tiger Wench]

Preseason in college football? Why not?
By RALPH D. RUSSO, AP College Football Writer

NEW YORK – Oregon State coach Mike Riley and the 24th-ranked Beavers open the season Saturday night in Arlington, Texas, against No. 6 TCU.

It just might be Oregon State's toughest game of the season and it will be the first time the Beavers have blocked or tackled an opponent since they played BYU in the Las Vegas Bowl in December.

Wouldn't it be nice for the Beavers if they could play a preseason game in August to get ready for the ones that count?

"I think that'd be awesome," Riley said recently.

While the NFL is considering cutting its preseason from four to two games (and lengthening its regular season), Riley and some other college coaches long for just one warm-up game or even a scrimmage against another team before the season starts.

"I was thinking about that the other day," Riley said. "It would be chance to see some new stuff and have your players have to adjust."

"What happens in the first game of the regular season, you take everything you've been working on and everything you do ... and then you've got to make some adjustments.

"I think a preseason scrimmage would give you the chance to get through some of the those hurdles and get your team to understand that that's the way it is every week. You've got to take what you do and adapt it."

Of course, Oregon State is the exception among top teams in major college football, many of which will open the season this weekend toying with weak opponents and playing their starters for a half.

But maybe teams would be more inclined to play a tough opener if they had a dress rehearsal?

NCAA rules allow Division I college football teams to play 12 contests, that includes scrimmages against other teams. Since no school is about to give up a regular-season game to play a game that doesn't count, the first step would be a rule change.

NCAA spokesman Erik Christianson said in an e-mail that "there have not been any proposals from member schools or conferences to change the rule on scrimmages or exhibition football games."

But maybe one might be coming.

Michigan coach Rich Rodriguez is a proponent of playing a preseason tuneup and apparently he's turned his new boss, athletic director David Brandon, on to the idea.

"Our coaches and I believe this is something worth considering," Brandon said. "We need to look at all of the issues carefully, and get input from other coaches and programs. However, it could be beneficial to provide a scrimmage opportunity versus another team during the preseason practice period to better prepare the team for competition. This would be for the same reasons that basketball, hockey, and other sports do the same thing."

At the lower levels of college football, it's not uncommon for teams to work in preseason intersquad scrimmages.

"We're probably one of the only levels of football that doesn't have preseason games," said Rodriguez, whose first college head coaching job was at Division II Glenville State.

Indiana coach Bill Lynch also coached in Division II.

"We'd find another school that was close, so it was relatively inexpensive and I thought it was really good. We used to really kind of make a day of it and it was really a practice against each other broken down into individual drills as well as 11 on 11.

"Whether that would work at this level, I'm not sure. I'm sure there would be finances that would get involved and probably try to make it a money maker. But in terms of getting your team ready, it would be great."

Rodriguez suggested limiting access so a preseason game doesn't turn into "a big event."

But there's the problem.

As Ohio State coach Jim Tressel put it, "If we were to play a preseason game, there would be 100,000-some people here."

When intrasquad spring games draw tens of thousands of fans at schools such as Nebraska, Alabama and Ohio State, it seems inevitable that even a bulked-up practice would become a major deal at the football factories.

While Rodriguez said he thinks most coaches would welcome an exhibition game of sorts, certainly not everyone would.

Count Stanford's Jim Harbaugh, who played in the NFL, and Arizona State's Dennis Erickson, who has coached in the NFL, among those who would stay with the status quo.

"The uniqueness of college football is a good thing, understanding that your going to see more fumbled snaps, more blocked punts, more miscommunication in the secondary, more missed tackles in that first game."

Erickson brought up the other big concern.

"To have it would be just an extra opportunity for guys to get hurt," he said.

Nebraska athletic director Tom Osborne isn't much for the idea of playing a preseason game, though he suggested the possibility of bringing in another team during the spring.

"I would sure hate to see them do anything to lengthen the season right now," he said.

At least one player, Notre Dame receiver Michael Floyd agrees with that.

"No reason for an extra game," he said. "I'm just ready for Purdue."

[Snaggletiger]

It's funny because I was discussing this very type thing the other day about how easy it would be for Auburn or Troy to load up a couple of busses and drive an hour to play some type of controlled scrimmage.  I think the players on both sides would get off on it getting to line up against someone other than the same ugly faces they beat on every day. 

[Ranger12]

I am not a fan of the NFL preseason games, so college would definitely not be something I be a fan of. I would think college coaches would have the same concerns that NFL coaches have...injuries in a game that does not even matter. Plus we need a playoff system before we need preseason college football.

[GH2001]

I am not a fan of the NFL preseason games, so college would definitely not be something I be a fan of. I would think college coaches would have the same concerns that NFL coaches have...injuries in a game that does not even matter. Plus we need a playoff system before we need preseason college football.

THIS

[AUChizad]

I am not a fan of the NFL preseason games, so college would definitely not be something I be a fan of. I would think college coaches would have the same concerns that NFL coaches have...injuries in a game that does not even matter. Plus we need a playoff system before we need preseason college football.

THIS.

It would make zero sense to have a "Preseason" game that "doesn't count" if we don't have any kind of playoff system in place.

Of course it would count, if it comes down to six one loss teams, but one lost to the Santa Cruz Banana Slugs in their "preseason" game.

[wesfau2]

THIS.

It would make zero sense to have a "Preseason" game that "doesn't count" if we don't have any kind of playoff system in place.

Of course it would count, if it comes down to six one loss teams, but one lost to the Santa Cruz Banana Slugs in their "preseason" game.

What do they look like, Jimmy?

Dorks.  They look like a couple of dorks.

Ha, ha, ha.  They're your clothes, motherfucker.

[AUChizad]

What do they look like, Jimmy?

Dorks.  They look like a couple of dorks.

Ha, ha, ha.  They're your clothes, motherfucker.

The scene you are referencing was in fact my muse for my obscure college reference.