The Strangers: Chapter 1I was never a huge fan of the first Strangers movie. The cast was good ( a werewolf and Liv Tyler), the story was solid, it was well shot. I just need a motive. I know real life isn't always that tidy, but if a group is torturing a couple my mind needs to know why. What's driving their mayhem? We never got that. Jason, Freddy, Michael, Hannibal, Dexter... we always know why. Not so with the Strangers. "Because you're here" is all we get.
Strangers Prey at Night was worse. Kind of stupid, actually.
I was apprehensive about Strangers: Chapter 1 but gave it a shot. It was better than I expected. It's not a sequel and not really a prequel. It's more of a reboot. It's set in Oregon where the first two were in Ohio (I think) but the Strangers characters are the same. I didn't hate it, thought it had some good moments.
It's still plagued by the same unanswered "why" question, but that bothered me less this time. Yes, it relied too heavily on the "weirdos in a small town and now my car won't start" cliches. No, the motivations were never fully explored.
The one thing that bothered me was the simp, cuck guy who wussily made bad decision after bad decision. I'm kind of tired of seeing weak, pussified guys being led by their female counterparts.
At the same time, that's where this movie actually excelled. The lead girl (Madelaine Grobbelaar Petsch) really, really worked for me. No idea who she is or where she came from, but she carried the role really well. She's a good actress. Beyond that, she seemed completely real. Not one of the fake/plastic Hollywood dolls with improbable proportions. Her mouth was adorable. The girl has a mouth that's almost a completely separate character and can act on its own. Amazing mouth. Her legs are thick and pale and juicy. She looked like a real girl. Realized when she was padding around in socks and an oversized button down just how long its been since we've seen a real human on the screen. Not a sickly looking twig with a pinched-in face and liposuctioned body. A real, live, normal girl. Loved it. More than anything else in this film, she made the difference and elevated it above what it could have been.
SPOLIER: DO NOT READ PAST THIS LINE IF YOU DON'T WANT TO KNOW.
Before I watched it, I didn't know Chapter 1 is only the first part of a trilogy. The movie doesn't end when it ends. It just goes to a To Be Continued... screen. THAT was annoying. I wish I'd known from the jump. I might still have watched it, but I might have waited until at least the second part came out. The good thing is the future films promise to explore the identity and motivation of The Strangers. That being the case, and knowing that Miss Petsch could potentially be back for Chapter 2? Kaos is in.