It's easy to have a 4.3 when your daddy is Oliver Luck.
So you factor in that this kid comes from a dirt poor shittastic situation where he obviously overachieved despite all of that...
And the coaches kept him on a string this whole time, to the point of him not even talking to other schools.
That was a shitty shitty thing to do.
Yes, I agree, but he has offers from other schools, including Tulane, which, granted, is not as good as Stanford, but isn't teh suxxors either. He can either wallow in his misery, or go get his education elsewhere.
In fairness to the coaches that "strung him along," according to them, they have zero say in admissions, and are contractually obligated not to interfere with admissions.