An observation....now that I have gotten to the middle of the Wickle jar.....
The smaller Wickles are best. The bigger ones just aren't as good.
To me it's all in the firmness. The smaller ones are usually very firm. The bigger ones are too mushy and there is nothing worse than a limp pickle. If it flops around when you wave it at someone, that's just no good.
I can't resist the kosher dill pickles at Katz's Deli and they are all small but firm. Excellent crunch when you bite.