You Can't Run Forever
Hey, JK Simmons.... you're in pretty much everything. You've won an Oscar, a BAFTA, a SAG, a Golden Globe, and a ton of other awards. You were a Nazi in Oz, Commissioner Gordon in Batman, JJ Jameson in Spiderman, a psychiatrist on Law & Order, Fred Mertz (from Lucy), the Farmer's Insurance guy AND the yellow M&M. How'd you like to barely stay awake for a formulaic, poorly-plotted film where you just kinda shoot people for no reason? Sound good? They're only gonna spend about $5 mil to make the movie, most of which will go to your salary, and it's gonna go straight to streaming. In? Perfect.
It's not that Simmons is bad in the role, it's just that after watching this guy terrorize as Nazi Vern Schillinger in Oz? I know what menace he's capable of oozing. His angry role in Whiplash was an extension of that in a lot of ways.
Here? He's about as menacing as he is in the Farmer's insurance ads. He's in it to make the paycheck and do as little as he can get away with.
Basic storyline: Film opens with Simmons character Wade shooting people at random at a gas station. He encounters a guy and his 18-year old stepdaughter - who climbs trees to deal with some internal trauma - and decides to target them next. In the final third of the movie the trigger for his psychotic break is exposed, but it rings really hollow. After encountering the girl and stepdad, he pursues her through the woods, accidentally aided by some inept deputies. The reason he chooses to follow her are barely touched on - and when they are, it's a stupid reason that made me roll my eyes. The film really follows the tired Final Girl trope with a little extra tacked on at the end.
For one brief second, close to the end of the film, you get a slight flash of the kind of menace Simmons could have brought to the role. In his eyes, in his expression, in his tone of voice. About the time you see it, though, it drops right off - almost as if he was internally like "I'm not putting that much effort into this..."
Simmons is an actor. A pretty good one, generally. Everyone else in the film would like to be an actor at some point, but the chance of any of them getting there seems remote. They aren't good.
The film is bogged down by lazy storytelling, enormous plot holes, abandoned story arcs, and inauthentic emotional reactions. Instantly forgettable.
Glad he got that check, though, he probably needed it.