Bleed For This
This is what Rocky MCMVXII should have been. Good story, true story of a kid with more heart than talent and a single-minded willingness to risk his life for something he wanted -- and the only thing he was really good at. It's also what Rocky MCMVXII didn't need to be: flat, leached of emotion, cardboard, dead. With the Rocky movies there was a good enough backstory that made you care about the characters. Here? There was really nobody to like. Maybe that's reality. But maybe it needed more.
Told the story of boxer Vinny Paz (he legally changed his name to this) and his return from a horrific car crash that left him millimeters away from being paralyzed with a broken neck. Against doctor's recommendation and the advice of everyone around him, he rejected neck fusion surgery which would have guaranteed he could walk but not box and opted for a metal halo which gave him the slim chance to get back in the ring.
The cast should have been first rate including Miles Teller, Aaron Eckhart, Katey Sagal, Ted Levine, Ciaran Hinds.
Teller, as Vinny P, was good and the fight scenes were realistic enough. More true to form than Rocky.
Sagal didn't have much to do. Her role could have been played by a chicken finger with no noticeable loss.
Eckhart left something to be desired as the paunchy, bald Kevin Rooney. Just didn't have the right spark.
Levine (it puts the lotion on its skin) was supposed to be Lou Duva but did so by making a peculiar squinched up face that was distracting and didn't have the ring of truth. Bad casting.
Hinds was a complete mess. I usually like the guy, but he was awful here. Bad directing maybe?
I liked the movie okay but it just didn't reach the emotional depths I needed it to. I wanted to like Vinny (Teller's character) but other than the fact that he just wanted to fight, there wasn't much about him to get behind. He wasn't likable.
I also noticed several liberties the movie took with the truth that were completely unnecessary. Most of the movie was fairly accurate, but why -- for instance -- change the scores the judges submitted for a fight that went the distance? Use the real damned scores. That wasn't part of my general letdown during the movie, but it made me think less of it after the fact.
The director shoehorned music in and out with some abrupt and jarring transitions. A song would just stop in the middle for no reason. The overall direction was clunky and ham handed. Made me wonder if this was the guy's debut film, because he made numerous seriously bad choices that detracted from the film. I checked. He's done a few films, but this was his baby. Wrote it, did the screenplay and directed. So the failures all land at his feet. And there were more than a few.
After I finished the film I looked up the real Vinny P and found him to be even more unlikable than the Teller version. He was a dumb punk with nothing going for him but a brash mouth-overloading-his-ass personality. Nothing appealing about him at all. Again, that didn't color my initial impression of the movie, but it absolutely made me care less about it looking back. It's not something I'd watch again.