Cap'n America: Winter Solider
and
Superman: Man of Steel
Watched both movies this weekend, one at the theater the other on HBO/Skinomax/Starz/Showtime whatever.
Did so purposely because I find similarities between the two characters and their "american way" patriotism. They are in some ways the DC/Marvel mirror image of each other just with different back stories.
Both are too bland by a degree to me. Neither has that jagged edge or inner demon or outsized alter ego that drive other major comic characters. Batman has the revenge factor, Spiderman also lost a paternal figure, Hulk was driven half mad by radiation, Iron Man has a recklessness, etc. Superman and the Captain are pure good in a world of evil. Both could use a little swagger, just a dash of Tony Stark's flippancy.
(Six is completely wrong and needs to get his own thread.)
If I'm ranking Marvel films, Captain America: Winter Soldier would fall behind Avengers, behind any of the Iron Man films and somewhere in a mix that includes the last Thor, the first Thor and the first Captain America. It would be above Ghost Rider, mainly because Nicholas Cage is one of the worst actors of our generation. His performance in GR: Spirit of Vengeance was laughable to the point of parody.
Captain America Winter Soldier was fair. It seemed a little disjointed in places and the ending seemed rush and almost artificial. No spoilers (not that there could really be any, honestly) but there are lots and lots of fights and the good guys sort of win in the end.
I found the underlying motivation of the bad guys to be a trifle asinine and it pained me to see Robert Redford in the role he took. Nazis in 2014 really? I understand the need to tie Captain to his frozen lost era, but the same story could have been told without the Nazi insinuations. Would probably have been better, actually.
The movie was at least 30 minutes longer than it needed to be. It could easily have trimmed out one or more of the repetitive shield-flinging fight scenes that dragged on and on.
It also suffers in comparison to The Avengers, Iron Man and even Thor all of which had opportunities for comic relief and were better paced. Each had a foil (whether it be Loki or Iron Man's own ego) that Captain was seriously lacking. The Captain was just too stuffed and taciturn.
Got zero bump from the bird dude. Expected he'd bring a different dynamic to the film and maybe that chance for some levity but it didn't happen.
And finally Scar-Jo didn't look well. Something was wrong with her face and it didn't show enough of her body to even it out.
On to Man of Steel.
I was pre-disposed to dislike the film. I'm a Batman guy and Batman guys typically aren't Superman fans. All of the Superman films I've seen to this point pretty much sucked. The ones with Keanau Reeves' father (or whoever that equestrian fellow was) were hokey and jokey. The one that destroyed Brandon Routh's career was pretty abysmal.
So I didn't have much hope for this Superman reboot and avoided it at the theaters. But given the weather and the opportunity to compare the boring Captain to the boring Superman, I took a chance.
Turns out I actually liked this film much better than Captain America. The guy playing Superman did well with the part. I found the Scrod guy's motivations to be a little far-fetched and the scenes on Krypton didn't really do a good job explaining why he would be so hell-bent on that level of fury.
In some ways the two films actually told the same story -- the destruction of earth's population in order to create a more perfect society -- but they came at it from different angles.
Not a fan of Amy Adams as Lois, for what it's worth. Not that Rachel McAdams or that creepy old Margot Kidder with her false teeth in the 70s were any better, though.
Got tired of watching buildings fall in Man of Steel. My daughter watched it with me and was reduced to going -- "there's another entire building hitting the ground." It's like since Transformers (or maybe before) these superhero directors seem obsessed with taking down high rises for dramatic effect. I got so weary of the constant stream of building, car, truck, store, street, tree, house and earth carnage.
As in Captain America, the fight scenes were just overlong and in the case of Superman, far too much collateral destruction.
Still, it was a story better told.
Superman was a B-. Winter Soldier was a mid to low C. Wish I hadn't spent the money to see Captain in theaters, wish I had spent it to see Man of Steel.