Gosling is good as supporting just not as lead.
Agree on Clooney. What do you think of Giamatti? Always thought he was underrated as well as Ray Liota and Don Cheadle.
Giamatti is good. Can do just about any role. He has some misses, but he usually handles every role well. I didn't care for Sideways and hate that he disgraced himself in Fred Claus. Did you know he had a bit part in one of my favorites Donnie Brasco? For me, Brasco is up there with Goodfellas and Casino. It combines mobsters, the 70s and Johnny Depp (in what's probably his strongest and least weird role). How can that go wrong?
Ray i don't think much of outside of Goodfellas. Maybe it's because he's taken roles in a ton of really shitty movies.
Cheadle is typically good but seems a little limited in the roles he can play. I've wanted to watch his new show House of Lies on Showtime but haven't gotten around to it yet. It's supposed to be good.
Also underrated IMO is McBongohey. He can't play every role, but he does smarmy cool as well as anyone. He needs to leave the romantic comedies behind.
"Actors" who cannot act?
Ryan Reynolds, Terrence Howard, Gerard Butler, Jason Statham, Ben Affleck, Vince Vaughn, all Owen brothers, Keanau, Ben Stiller (and everyone in his movies), Hayden Wan Kenobi, Adam Sandler (and everyone in his movies like Kevin James), Channing Tatum, Dennis Quaid, Russell Crowe (except for Gladiator), Dane Cook, Ashton Kutcher, Paul Walker and Brendan Fraser.
The worst of the worst:
3) Butler -- Exception 300 but only because it opened the door for Spartacus
2) Travolta -- exception Welcome Back Kotter and Pulp Fiction
1) Nicholas Cage -- exception Raising Arizona and Valley Girl to a degree