I’ve been holding off watching Joker, because, like you, I’ve been a Batman fan my whole life. And I don’t think the Joker needs an origin story, even though I really enjoyed Killing Joke (the comic, haven’t seen the movie). Quite frankly, I don’t believe the Joker knows his own origin, since he’s insane. That’s why I believe it changes in the comic. Is Killing Joke his origin? Could be, depending on Joker’s mood at the time.
I supposed I’ll eventually watch it, though.
Killing Joke is a very good graphic novel. Somewhere around here I've got an original printing from the 90s. That was when I was still hitting the comic stores occasionally looking for treasure.
Best things I have (although not necessarily the most valuable)? A set of Kamandi in really good shape. Pristine copy of Batman 400. A VG Batman comic from about 1960. Entire first year of The Dark Knight series (including variant covers). But I'm getting off track.
I've heard many people say this version of the Joker origin was based on that novel. But it wasn't. It took a tiny piece of it -- pre-lunatic joker was a failed comedian -- and layered all the Bernie Sanders/AOC socialist, rise up against the evil rich people nonsense on top of it.
If you remember Killing Joke, the guy who became Joker had a decent job and a family. He QUITS his job to pursue the dream of becoming a comedian. He fails spectacularly and in an effort to survive agrees to help some thugs rob the place where he used to work. While he's setting that up, his wife and child are killed in an accident. He wants to grieve, but the thieves force him to continue his role in their caper. The robbery goes awry, the dude gets disfigured and the combination of that and the loss of his family pushes him over the edge into insanity.
This movie? ENTIRELY different.
The insanity is already there, but the evil rich people don't let him have access to satisfactory treatment. (Free healthcare!!). The rich people don't care about the plight of the poor! (Every Bernie/Elizabeth/AOC/Islamihan rally ever). The only solution is to wear masks and rise up against the 1%! Take their shit by any means necessary. Riot! Attack the rich people! Attack the police. (Antifa).
The first time I watched it I was too busy following the story to really grasp all the underlying socialist bullshit it's filled with. The second time, it overwhelmed me. I saw it for what it really, truly is.
Every Batman film or story I've ever seen has portrayed Thomas Wayne as a decent, honorable, philanthropic man of integrity. This movie? He's a bullying, narcissistic, snobbish, brutish asshole. That's not the Gotham we want or need. It's not the reality (I know it's not real, but still...). It's a twisted perversion of the mythology. How long before it's spun around so that Batman's the bad guy?
It's not a superhero/super-villain movie. It's nothing but socialist propaganda.
But don't listen to me. Watch it for yourself and see what you see.