Us
Jordan Peele is being hailed as the great visionary in the horror genre. He made a complex, layered film in Get Out that was much deeper than the usual chop-em-up, possessed-by-a-demon fare that qualifies as horror. His new film, Us, follows a similar path in that it's got so many different levels and reflects a much deeper meaning.
Problem is that neither Get Out or Us are truly exercises in horror. They're both psychological puzzles designed not to scare necessarily, but to get the viewer thinking about societal issues in a different way. Peele makes good movies, but I'm not entirely comfortable with the manipulation to promote his own personal/philosophical/political views.
In Us a very white black family takes a vacation trip to a seaside town where the wife grew up. The wife is hiding a horrible history in the town from her husband, and predictably the history comes back to haunt them.
The problems begin when a mirror-image family appears in the driveway of the vacation home. Doppelganger dad, mom, son and daughter then attempt to murder the originals in an effort to take their place.
The movie then morphs into an extended series of hand-to-hand brawls. As the whiteblack family fights back against their identical attackers, they discover that they are not alone in the fight. Everyone in the world is battling their own duplicates. As the bloody, brutal fights rage on, the story of where these duplicates come from is slowly unspooled.
That part of the film is less than satisfying. Where the duplicates were for years, how they were created, why they exist, how they live, and why they decided to emerge to confront the originals doesn't really make sense, is poorly portrayed and generates more questions than it answers. It seems contrived and almost tacked on because Jordan decided at the last minute he needed to explain them somehow. Might have been better if their origin had been left a complete mystery. I think it made more sense in Jordan's head than it did on the screen.
I also didn't understand or agree that the vengeance of one would be transformed into the vengeance of many. The rationale for that massive undertaking by the duplicates was not given enough exposition.
The movie was fairly well acted, had a good mix of drama and comedy, and almost kept the big twist from being obvious. Granted, I suspected what was coming less than 15 minutes along, but I don't think everyone saw it coming.
It still wasn't what I'd consider horror. It felt more like an extended episode of the Twilight Zone.