Holy. Shit. You guys never would have entertained that notion 2-3 years ago. All we could hear in 2007 was how CTT was unstoppable, and nobody could compare to his greatness. Funny how things change so quickly....
Hyperbole aside, 2008 was the first year in a long time that Tubs didn't appear to be getting it done.
And the main point of my post was obviously missed. If you're going to compare him to Tubs, use the same timeframe. I'd say so far Chizik has exceeded the expectations set for him far more than Tubs had by month four.
And I disagree with this:
The situation he came in to post Bowden is vastly different than what he left Chizik
No depth, no apparent QB, no standout playmakers. How are you going to act as if Tubs set Chizik up for success and he's not living up to potential?