If you ever watched Columbo you might find yourself wondering how he somehow got reincarnated into the misshapen, frizzy-haired body of 'Charlie', the human lie detector who is the centerpiece of this new Peacock series.
The show has the same opening look as the opening of Columbo from coloring to font to graphics. It has the same format as Columbo. You see what happened, know who did it and then work backward as oddball Charlie - played by Natasha Lyonne figures the crime out. It uses the same reliance as Columbo on episode-by-episode special guest stars. Columbo was Dick Van Dyke, Leonard Nimoy, William Shatner, Vincent Price, etc. Poker Face is Benjamin Bratt, Adrian Brody, Chole Sevigny, Judith Light, Ellen Barkin, Tim Meadows, etc.
It's so similar, I expect the quirky Charlie to stop at the door and turn to the suspect and say "just one more thing..." At some point I'm pretty sure it will happen, honestly.
The difference? Columbo was a detective, solving the crimes for law enforcement. Charlie is a hustler, on the run from a casino owner who travels around the country in a beat to shit vintage car, picking up odd jobs. Wherever she goes, she happens to turn up just as a murder (or attempted murder) occurs. Her gift for knowing when somebody is lying ends up being crucial to solving what would ordinarily be an unsolvable case.
Lyonne's Charlie is a odd one. She's bizarrely charming and is clearly having fun in the role. But she looks like she would smell like three-day-old ass sweat, stale cigarettes and dirty socks.
If you liked Columbo (and I did) this is an obvious homage to the dogged detective in almost every way. But it's not quite as good.