You have to do what is best for the team THIS YEAR. If Trotter is the best thing for the team this year, you play him this year. There is no telling what will happen 3, 4 or even 5 years down the road. Who knows, Cotton may be better than all 3 of them combined, he may be a flop. There may be a dude right now in the 9th grade that is a HUGE Auburn fan that could be the next coming of Bret Favre. You just don't know. If Trotter can help the team this year, I say play him. It is not fair to the senios that have worked their ass off for 4 years to just say "fuck this year, we will try again next year". Most of these kids will never get to play football again and it would be bullshit to just piss away half of their senior year...just because...