As Wes said, the committee is the one part I don't like either. It may take some ironing out. My point though? Its better than anything we've had thus far in determining the best football team in the country.
Agreed.
I said early in these restructuring discussions that I'm not sure about this committee.
That being said, I can't imagine it being worse and less informed than the coaches' poll. I'd like to see computers continue to play a role, but if I had to change them, make them more transparent. Expose the formulas.
No matter what, 4 > 2. Would I prefer 8? Yes. But, still 4 > 2.