This is where you're going wrong.
Just stick to how Coach Chizik's decisions are helping AU's recruiting. Saban and Alabama are still going to have a top 3 class this year.
Clearly, Saban's recruiting practices, and "processing" practices are not favored by every recruit or parent of same, just like Auburn doesn't feel like family to every recruit, but many do feel that and gravitate to it. But it doesn't "hurt" him enough to really kill any recruiting class.