Clearly, it turned out spectacular for Florida this season.
And don't forget Auburn 2005-2007 either.
It's been working out quite well for Alabama lately. And it's not like they have a great QB or receivers. Pretty good OL, thought. UF is a bad example, because this is their first year running pro-style. As Prowler mentioned, it will take them a few years to get the right personnel for that, compared to the offense they have the shelves stocked for.
Part of the problem is I don't think you quite understand some folks' argument. I think everybody understands, and concedes, that AU has alot of youth on both sides of the ball; particularly on offense. Nobody expected results like last season. From most people, I've found the following arguments to be the most valid:
1. There are two upperclassmen at QB who have been in the system numerous years. It shouldn't have been a big surprise this season that that neither are worth a shit. Obviously having a shitty QB and youth on the OL don't mix. One can act as a crutch for the other to an extent. But WHY are there two upperclassmen that are shitty, and more importantly, WHY wasn't this identified sooner and players (JUCO?) recruited to fix that? Everybody knows you're not going to get good results with a shitty QB. Nobody can understand WHY there are shitty QBs with no valid replacements.
2. Youth in large quantities will result in some losses. But when you have the youth that has been recruited at the talent level that AU has been recruiting at the past 3 years, there should be something to show for it. It shouldn't look like a Chinese fire drill every Saturday, and shouldn't result in 30 point blowouts against any team halfway worth a shit.
I know that, given the opportunity, you would suck Malzahn's cock. That's cool. But from the outside looking in, those arguments above aren't really that unreasonable. Everybody knows Malzahn is somewhat limited when you don't have the players to run it. But everybody wants to know, given the players that have been recruited (after factoring in youth), why he doesn't have something that looks halfway decent. The reason why some are looking at the coaches, I think, is because of the QB situation and how that seems to have been mishandled. There is no way in hell they didn't know that Trotter/Moseley weren't going to be good. They couldn't be this shitty on the field, but showing extreme talent on the practice field the past two years. No way. That's why they wanted Cam.