Andre Ware as well.
Salaam maybe?
I was focusing on guys who won solely because they were on the #1 team, but there are a lot of other guys who could be included if you are just talking about bad choices.
But, I could see why Andre Ware won. He was the first guy to put up video game numbers at QB because of the system he played in. That was a new thing then so people didn't know what to do with it and voted for him. You can see how people didn't understand the concept of "system QB" yet when Detroit drafted him in the first round.
Salaam just looks bad because he busted out in the NFL. He actually put up huge numbers at Colorado with over 2000 yds which is still a fairly big deal in a major conference. If I remember right that was a three man race between him, Kijana Carter (my personal favorite, I really followed Penn State back then during the Carter/Curtis Enis days
) and Kerry Collins. Carter and Salaam put up similar numbers and Collins wasn't even the best player on his own team.