I started to pick up a bottle today of the Midnight moon and remembered what you said. I just went with a standard stop of Elijah Craig 12 year and Eagle Rare. The Jefferson's Reserve caught my eye, but at $50 a 750ml made me rethink that decision. Had a bottle of Bulleit not long ago. Not bad stuff, not bad at all.
Here lately I have been drinking a lot of the Craig. So smooth for a 94 proof.
Elijah Craig is 12 year is now my go to bourbon, you just can't go wrong with it. The guy at the local liqour store said the E. Craig 18 year was the best bottle of bourbon they have in the store. I haven't pulled the trigger yet, it's in the $50 range also. Why pay $50 for one great bottle when you can get two very good bottles for the same price?
Another bourbon that I tried recently, quite similar to E. Craig, is 1792 Ridegmont Reserve. Same price point as Craig. Give it a shot if you ever see it.