This is my overall opinion on Cam Newton.
The reading and retention part has to come in the pro game to take a team to the playoffs. Had John Elway gone to Baltimore things might have been very different for him although we all agree that the game is played differently today.
Big Ben is almost dinosaurlike as a QB. The opposition hangs on him as he delivers an ugly ball by most standards, but as effectively as a SS-Rodgers or 3B-Brady. What sets these guys apart is their resillience or unflappability. They can fail and overcome by correcting their own errors and by not repeating the same mistake twice or even more. They understand that their place is to find the playmakers as quickly and precisely as they can. It is all about them but I liken what they do to a game of chess with a timer. The game is often decided by a few moves be it success or failure.
Cam gets the glamorous, it's a business, entertaining part of the game. The Jay Barker's and Jason Campbell's can generally make the throws and provide the necessary leadership of the position, but there is an element missing that marginalizes their games. And Cam is neither of these because of his personality. So to me it's the speed of the game and setting up the pieces with quick consise decisionmaking according to the overall gameplan set by the staff that knows the opponents strengths and weaknesses.
We know Cam can run, and the great ones always do in crunchtime when the game's on the line. We know he can make all of the throws which is basically an NFL requirement. Moreover, can he perform all of these acts while being persued by NFL defenders? I don't know if he can. But I would not bet against this young man because of what I saw him do this season, at Auburn, in one season, with a better than a good overall supporting cast, surrounded by controversy, amongst all of the questions concerning his father, his character and his honesty.
It is said he is a polarizing figure and he is compared by many to Vince Young. I don't think Cam Newton is a headcase. He is an Alpha-male, never doubting his abilities, not one that makes excuses, or the type that sulks. Newton might struggle with a team with marginal talent that can't really protect him, but this is the guy that can get some seasoning and weather the storm until proper help arrives if that organization is truly set on winning. Naysayers even have to admit that Cam is an extremely gifted talent while internally predicting his ultimate failure in the NFL as a QB for various reasons, some not worthy of mention. The NFL purist can point to the technical flaws that dual threat QBs generally struggle with yet cannot explain Ryan Leaf.
But to the Auburn family, Cam Newton is OUR GUY and WE know that Cam Newton is no ordinary human being. The NFL wants Cam Newton to succeed. He is good for the game and he is a money maker and I have no doubt that he will deliver in time as a regular in the playoffs, perhaps even some Super Bowls.